Kentucky Owl Rye Batch 2 Whiskey Review: A Friendly Look at This Popular Spirit

thewhiskylady - 2024-01-30

Maker’s Mark Cask Strength vs Old Weller Antique 107: A Comparison of Two Popular Bourbons

thewhiskylady - 2024-01-30

Eagle Rare Store Pick Review: A Friendly Guide to Choosing Your Next Bottle

thewhiskylady - 2024-01-30
Kentucky Owl Rye Batch 2 Whiskey Review
Eagle Rare Store Pick Review

Eagle Rare is already a fantastic bourbon, but the store pick takes it to another level.

For those who may not be familiar, Eagle Rare is a 10-year-old bourbon produced by Buffalo Trace Distillery. It’s made from the same mash bill as Buffalo Trace and George T. Stagg and is known for its smooth, mellow flavor profile. The store pick version of Eagle Rare is selected by a specific retailer or group of retailers and is often a single barrel or a small batch that has been hand-selected for its unique flavor profile.

Eagle Rare Store Pick Overview

Product History

Eagle Rare is a well-known brand of bourbon whiskey that is produced by the Buffalo Trace Distillery. It is a part of the company’s Antique Collection, which also includes other popular brands such as George T. Stagg and William Larue Weller.

The brand was first introduced in 1975, and it quickly gained popularity among whiskey lovers. Its smooth and rich flavor profile, combined with its affordable price, has made it a go-to choice for many people.

Price Range

Eagle Rare Store Picks are typically more expensive than the regular release bottles. The price can vary depending on the store or group that selects the barrel. However, the average price range for a store pick is between $60 and $100.

It is important to note that the price may be higher or lower depending on the location and availability of the bottle. Some stores may charge a premium for their store picks, while others may offer them at a discount.

Eagle Rare Store Pickphoto credit:

Tasting Notes


I was immediately struck by the rich fruit scents of Luxardo cherries and apricot jelly. The caramel and butterscotch notes added a pleasant sweetness and were a great complement to the spicy notes of cinnamon and allspice. The aroma was well-balanced and inviting.


On the palate, I tasted upfront notes of honey, toasted brown sugar, new oak, and light traces of white pepper. While not particularly deep, it was very tasty and enjoyable. The sweetness from the aroma carried over to the flavor, and the spice notes added a pleasant kick.


The finish was medium in length, with the sweetness and spice notes lingering on the tongue. There was a slight bitterness towards the end, but it was not overpowering and did not detract from the overall experience.


Overall, I would rate this Eagle Rare Store Pick as a solid choice. While it may not be the most complex or nuanced bourbon out there, it is very tasty and easy to drink. I would recommend it to both seasoned bourbon drinkers and those who are new to the spirit. On a scale of 1-10, I would give it an 8.

Mixing and Pairing

Best Mixersphoto credit:

Best Mixers

When it comes to mixing Eagle Rare Store Pick, I prefer to keep it simple and let the whiskey shine. Club soda is a great option for a refreshing and simple sparkling drink, while ginger ale or ginger beer can add a spicy kick to the bourbon’s flavors. If you’re feeling adventurous, try mixing Eagle Rare with high-quality tonic water for a unique twist on a classic gin and tonic.

Cocktail Suggestionsphoto credit:

Cocktail Suggestions

Eagle Rare Store Pick is a versatile bourbon that can be used in a variety of cocktails. For a classic Old Fashioned, muddle a sugar cube with a few dashes of bitters, add a splash of water, and stir in two ounces of Eagle Rare Store Pick. For a refreshing summer cocktail, mix Eagle Rare with lemonade and a splash of triple sec. And for a festive winter drink, try mixing Eagle Rare with hot apple cider and a cinnamon stick.

Food Pairingsphoto credit:

Food Pairings

Eagle Rare Store Pick pairs well with a variety of foods, from grilled meats to rich desserts. For a savory pairing, try serving Eagle Rare with a charcuterie board featuring cured meats and aged cheeses. For a sweet pairing, try pairing Eagle Rare with a slice of pecan pie or a dark chocolate truffle. And for a unique pairing, try serving Eagle Rare with a spicy Thai or Indian dish to complement the bourbon’s spicy notes.


The store pick I tried had a slightly different flavor profile than the standard Eagle Rare. It was still smooth and mellow, but had a bit more complexity and depth. I highly recommend seeking out a store pick of Eagle Rare if you have the chance. It’s a great way to experience a unique and delicious variation of an already fantastic bourbon.

I highly recommend giving the Eagle Rare Store Pick a try if you’re a fan of bourbon. Just be sure to do your research and choose a store pick that fits your flavor preferences.

Related Posts

If you’re a fan of Eagle Rare Store Pick, you might also want to check out some of these other whiskey reviews:

Please add social media services by going to 'Theme Options > Social > Add share services'